
2026 Seminar Series
LIBERTY
On Freedom of Belief
Dr. Heather Rabenberg
Assistant Professor, SUNY Brockport
Thursday, November 19 at 7 pm
Wegmans School of Pharmacy, Room 129
St. John Fisher University

This talk examines whether, and in what way, we believe freely. That is, we will consider whether we have anything like voluntary control over our beliefs. If we do not, then it might seem we lack responsibility for our beliefs. This is particularly concerning when it comes to beliefs we hold dear. I will consider a novel solution to this puzzle, sometimes called the puzzle of doxastic voluntarism. I will argue for what I call the normative limits solution to this puzzle which seeks to vindicate our voluntary control over our beliefs and our responsibility for them.
The Value of Liberty for St. Thomas Aquinas
Dr. Stephen Loughlin
President, St. Bernard's School of Theology and Ministry
Thursday, October 22 at 7 pm
Wegmans School of Pharmacy, Room 129
St. John Fisher University

Dietrich von Hildebrand's Cooperative Freedom: Understanding Freedom as Self-Donation
Dr. Alexander Montes
University of Rochester
Thursday, September 24 at 7 pm
School of Pharmacy, Room 129
St. John Fisher University

In this talk, I argue that Dietrich von Hildebrand, a student of Edmund Husserl (the father of phenomenology) and strident opponent of Nazism, provides a unique answer to the age-old question of how freedom, which seems to involve doing what we want without restraints, can be reconciled with morality, which imposes such restraints. This unique answer is best brought out in contrast to the more famous but problematic answer Immanuel Kant gives to the same question. Kant identifies freedom with autonomy, with the tragic consequence that freedom is either closed to the experience of the Other, or it becomes detached from morality, a law unto itself. By contrast, Hildebrand’s analysis of freedom shows that freedom is rather what I will term the autonomous assumption of heteronomy. Freedom is giving one’s fiat, “let it be,” to being moved by a potential motive that is essentially distinct from one, outside of oneself. This unifies freedom with affective love in a way that is not possible for Kant. For Hildebrand, freedom is ultimately found in self-donation and cooperation with the deepest stirrings of our heart, and, ultimately, the grace of God.
Militarism & Freedom
Dr. Stephen Sims
Associate Professor, Political Science
Rochester Institute of Technology
Saturday, April 11 at 11 am
Max Lowenthal Hall
Room 3105
RIT
Dr. Sims will argue that the project of liberal hegemony seeks to eliminate war in order to secure individual freedom, but in doing so risks eliminating politics itself by removing real conflict and meaningful collective decision-making. Drawing on Aristotle and Plato, he proposes that genuine political life, and thus human flourishing, requires the possibility of real conflict, best preserved in a world of competing powers rather than a single, pacified global order.

Seminars are free and open to the public
Students that attend the series may request a certificate of completion
Previous Seminar Series: Intersections (2022) Beauty (2022-2023) Happiness (2024). Reality (2025)
For more information write to: contact@agathoninstitute.org






